Alts plan has one flaw you cant manage a whole state the way he is trying to do it. In the area where our camp is we had 16 guys for a week and didnt kill a deer. We voted not to take does because of the low deer numbers. There are places in PA. that does have more deer than it can support but there are also places that dont. The game commission needs to address this problem before they try to do this statewide. As for bigger racks why does everyone have a antler fetish? Any deer taken legally and ethically is a trophy to someone. What gives some people the right to tell me or anyone else what they should shoot? If a person is happy shooting spikes and small bucks so what? If you want to hold out for a big buck that is up to you but dont put down the person that chooses not to. The old argument take does for meat doesnt wash with me. I have shot more does than bucks anyway and will still continue to shoot does but I am concerned about the way deer management is taking in Pa.