HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - please tell me just one negative to crossbows
Old 04-08-2005 | 02:49 PM
  #1099  
MA Jay
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 801
Likes: 0
Default RE: please tell me just one negative to crossbows

Legal definition.
BigJ, why do you think your dictionary makes for the legal definiton of archery and what a bow? What about these dictinary's?

From the Merriam-Webster Dictionary-
Main Entry: cross·bow
Pronunciation: -"bO
Function: noun
: a weapon for discharging quarrels and stones that consists chiefly of a short bow mounted crosswise near the end of a stock
This crossbow definition calls a crossbow a "weapon" that consists of a short bow mounted on a stock. Now I know you are smart, if the dictionary said a crossbow was actually a "bow" it would say that, but it doesn't it calls it a "weapon" it's own weapon that is made with a bow and stock and other parts. In fact that is what the crossbow definition is ... a description of the actual weapon, and no where does it call it a bow.

From the Webster-Merriam dictionary again
Main Entry: 3bow
Pronunciation: 'bO
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English bowe, from Old English boga; akin to Old English bugan
1 a : something bent into a simple curve b : RAINBOW
2 : a weapon that is made of a strip of flexible material (as wood) with a cord connecting the two ends and holding the strip bent and that is used to propel an arrow
3 : ARCHER
and Archer's definiton
Main Entry: ar·cher
Pronunciation: 'är-ch&r
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English, from Old French, from Late Latin arcarius, alteration of arcuarius, from arcuarius of a bow, from Latin arcus bow -- more at ARROW
1 : a person who uses a bow and arrow
Now I read that definiton of what a bow is and what an archer is .. and no where does it mention crossbows. It doesn't say a strip of flexible material with a cord connecting 2 ends used to propel arrows AND is mounted on a stock AND fires quarrels and stones. It's now there.... please read it.

Now I also don't believe a dictionary defines anything "legally". State. Local and Federal law do that. We've discussed at length their definitons, and how crossbows are not legally defined as bows.
MA Jay is offline  
Reply