This may be a little biased as im a remington man, but i have hunted with a rem pump and have never had any problems, 1187 and have had a few problems due to owner negligence. Some of the older 3 1/2 mossburgs used to jamm. The binelli pump never really fit me but the SBE fit really good just a little to picky on shells for me. Hope this not to biased opinion, good luck with whatever you buy. Let us know which one you decide to buy so we can give you a hard time on jump on the band wagon.