I read more here rather then post....however this may be an idea 4U
I have seen over and over again people asking about a recommendation of a outfitter. There are other sites which allow you to "rate/search for your outfitter" I use it often for both looking for a new place as well as giving feed back.
Just a note..if you do something like this it is best if people "pick" from a list on each question. Such as "how was the food?" Poor/ Fair / average / Good / Excellant
It is easier to compare rather than have everyone just write at random. All the ones I have been on is broken down by States / provinces
There can be a small comment place for Misc info that someone may feel they need to convey.