IMHO I think it's sending a wrong message to a kid starting out. I'd rather teach my sons how to "hunt" a truely wild animal. Seems to me like it's starting them out the easy way by by guaranteeing sighting and a harvest. I'd rather see them learn the finer points and appreciate everything else that goes along with hunting rather than simply killing something. Let em earn their stripes so to speak. If that's the message we want to deliver to the future of our sport then we are in BIG trouble.
As for the fishing analogy>?? You don't start out stocking your bathtub with sunfish and sit in the bathroom catching them do ya?
Just my opinion of course. To each their own. I've argued this high fence thing to the point of giving me an ulcer.