StraightArrow I can't take it any longer, I think ones perspective on this topic of passing yearling bucks has much to do with where you hunt.

Many states have a lease system that allows a group of hunters to purchace or lease the exclusive rights to hunt on a certain piece of property each year. Many of the leases in my area are contracts drawn up with timber companies, some are from private individuals. But reguardless, most of these groups adopt rules that are designed to allow the young bucks to mature. Generaly these groups will target a certain age class of deer (bucks) for harvesting. Many target 2 1/2 year olds but the better, more expensive land tracts don't even consider harvesting a buck deer untill he's reached 5 1/2. But virtually "all" the ethical members (probably 90%) of these clubs pass on small bucks every year.

Now I have hunted some public land that recieves much pressure. If that was the only experience I could draw from I too, would believe that 90% of the hunters shoot everything that walks. The difference is you aparently have not been fortunate enough to enjoy the thrill of hunting one of these, even marginally managed ranches. There is much pleasure in watching a nice, young 8 pt. walk under your stand and just knowing he'll be there next year....

KEEP THE WIND IN YOUR FACE.... FLETCH