The question isn't intended for any one individual.

I'll revise the question to hopefully make it more "understandable".

If a hunter goes out of his/her way to harvest their full quota of doe each year but still continues to harvest one imature basket racked buck every year (because they choose to do so) , is that acceptable behavior?
Notice the original question states "regardless of hunters age/experience or geographical location.

Afterall , they are keeping the buck to doe ratio in check.