Great post, man, I applaud you. My own personal philosophy on here is to get on and learn from all the great hunting minds. My personal learning style is fairly confrontational, I like to lay out a theory and see if I can defend it, or if somebody can blow it out of the water. Even though I will argue a point at the drop of a hat, I try to keep my ego out of it.

Also, I see no value in the type of post where the first guy says something like "the only way to hunt whitetails is from a tree stand", and then you get 55 consecutive guys saying "yeah, you da' man, that's exactly what I think". How valuable is that? Personally, if I read a post that I agree with, I often just read it and go my merry way. Most of my responses are to the 10% of posts I disagree with, then I let go with both barrels. Again, I think there's more value in developing different sides of an issue, and let people figure out who they think is "right", or what will work in their hunting area.