I say if you shoot a doe then good job, good for you. If you shoot an immature buck and it's your first then I say good job, good for you. If you shoot an immature buck and you've been hunting for 10+ years and immature bucks are mostly all you've ever shot then I say bad job, shame on you, raise your standards and if you claim you just want meat then shoot another doe! If you shoot a nice mature buck, then I say, nice trophy...congratulations!