Farm Hunter,

I also think that the first two pictures are of different deer. The first picture looks like an older deer then the 2nd picture because of the thickness of its neck and body. I think the first deer also has more muscle tone as well. Then again, it could just be the photo angle. On the first two deer, my guess on age would be 3.5 and 2.5. However, I am far from an expert, and I am using deer characteristics from my neigberhood to judge the ages of deer in your area which can always lead to mistakes. Either way, if they are around next year, they should get heart pumping if you get a shot at them.