farm hunter, the deer in the first and second picture are two 'different' deer.
I opened the picture of the first deer using Adobe and changed the brightness and contrast and you can clearly see the first deer is different. It has 3 points on the left side and four on his right. He even has a small 'drop tine' close to his ear--if you look carefully at your picture you will see the drop tine just above 'his right ear'.
Don't know how to post pictures here, otherwise I would have shown you what it looked like after the brightness and contrast was adjusted.