RE: Tipping your guide
Mr. Long I dont see anything wrong with what you came up with. Most people that have never taken a hunt outside of their own state see a hunt "cost" and think that is the bottom line. Its typically only half or not even that much of the total expense. Yep $5k is the hunt and thats ALL. It doesnt involve airfare, rental car (unless you are in a remote, pack in type hunt I strongly recommend getting your own wheels for a hunt) meat processing fees, taxidermy and shipping and yes TIPPING. Like I said, most hunt "costs/fees" end up typically being only 1/3-1/2 of the bottom line net cost of a hunt.
Thats something for ALL to consider before thinking, "Hey if I save up $10k for that Yukon mixed bag hunt, I'm IN like flint". Only to become broken hearted when they forgot to add XYX dollars for airfare, taxidermy fees, shipping and handling of trophies (FedEx/UPS doesnt work for charity!) rental car (again if applicable) and PROPER and REASONABLE tips. By the time its all said and done such a trip will usually run you in the $15k+ range.
But I honestly dont see the gripe. Expecting a "$5k hunt to strictly cost $5k" is un-realistic and very un-reasonable if you ask me. I suppose by some here's logic, they can go look at a FX4 CrewCab XLT Ford and cuss everyone out because it doesnt cost the same as the base model 2x4 6cyl 150 sitting beside it?
Hey I wish EVERYONE the luck, success and chance to pursue the trophies of their dreams at least once in their lifetimes. But if they are gonna moan and complain about the price and feel that they should get "the whole enchilada" just because they paid a hunt fee, thats just not right if you ask me. The whole idea of "hunt fee" is just that. Its payment for just what it implies... "the hunt itself". NOT for taking care of those who helped/fed you, got you there, picked you up at the airport, caped and cared for your trophy, etc...
Be reasonable,
RA