I have a Pieta replica of an 1851 Confederate Navy .44 cap & ball. Out of a dozen assorted, it just might be the most accuate handgun I own. It's easy to shoot a 4" pattern at 20-25 yards. Cleaning isn't too bad if you use Pyrex P powder. The only thing is, I would hate to be loading it with someone shooting at me.

If I got another BP revolver, and I may, I think I would get an 1858 with a top strap and quick change cylinders. That way, if you get several spare cylinders, you can fire more rounds without stopping to reload.

And, to answer your original question, BP revolvers are serious weapons, not just toys or curios. They're also considered antiques and do not require federal paperwork to purchase. Cabela's sells them by mail order.

clunker