Let me recomend the Sonic Broadhead by American Broadhead Company!! They are unbelievable! They fly exatly like field points and penetrate like crazy! I saw a video they use to promote it and it showed in slow motion a 100 grain Broadhead go through a black bear and then pass through both side of the bait barrel!! But more importantly it is dead accurate! I have personally shot them and they are awesome. I am like you I would rather shoot a broadhead that fly where I want it to and have a smaller cutting diameter than one that flies everywhere with 2 inches of cutting diameter!