I usually take a doe or 2 in early bow season and buck hunt during the rut. I can't tell the difference in the meat as both are good eating. I agree that a hunter should take mature does and pass on young bucks but as long as you're following hunting regulations for your area it's really up to the individual hunter. I've really made an effort in the past 2 years to identify button bucks and let them walk but I don't rag on other hunters if they kill them as long as their legal.