Since you seem to have a problem with our little club, I thought I'd point out some of our basic rules.

In addition to the typical fair chase, legal, ethical requirements we all agree to the following

Our members agree to shoot only mature bucks (125" or better)

Our members agree to shoot a doe. Most are archers and do it early

It works very well for us. We have a good balance of Bucks to does. One third of our membership killed a 125 or better buck this year.

Yep, it's private land, Yep it's another state but they're still whitetails and 90% of our membership is PA guys who practice the same thing at home.