RE: What makes some Venison taste Gamey?
I think it can be a combination of things gone wrong can take it from "a little gamey" to untolerable.
Bad shots that let it run live or other wise saturate the meat with adrenaline. I just don't think this can be fixed by marinating or anything else.
Trim off all the fat.
Assuming everything else is at least addressed in a reasonable manner I've never had any gamey taste at all. It still taste like venison but none of that bitter or at least that's what I call gamey taste.
Many times I've cooked a neck roast from one like this in a crock pot and cooked just like beef most people can't tell it from beef even when both are right there at the table.
Steaks still taste like venison but I don't do a thing different to them than I do to beef steaks.