Why would the guy want to keep your arrow? And only one? He works for a shop I doubt he has trouble getting arrows. Most likely he just forgot it, it happens.

Maybe you should have checked to see if you had everything before your left, then you wouldn't have to drive over there and get it.

Yes, I think you are blowing it out of proportion. You know what else gives us a bad name? People who blame others unjustly or for honest mistakes. I think your a bit paranoid myself, and if you accuse this guy of something good luck ever getting a job there.

I'm sure they guy feels bad about, just go back and get your arrow. If he appologizes accept it graciously and be done with it. You might make a freind out the guy or something. You never know.

Paul