I agree with everything you said. However if a tid bit of information can help the person recover their deer by posting something, then it's worth it. Yes 99% of the time there is nothing we can tell them to help. They ultimately will be the only ones to figure it out and should have more tracking knowledge, better understanding of shot placement, etc..... But the thing is unfortunately it's not going to change. It's going to continue to happen. Because a person doesnt' post their story here doesn't mean they arent' going to go in the woods and wound a deer. So, other than the painful disgustingly sick nature of some of the stories, I'd rather see them and possibly help. JMO