well if it were a scrape and had just been made Id hunt over that for a couple of days cuz hes likely to come freshen it up. But the ? would be what time is he visiting that scrape. A rub line would depend on which way it was running to and from the area I hunted. Both are good to hunt but figuring out the time is the key. Id much rather hunt over a fresh scrape especially during the rut. early season id hunt the rubs.