ORIGINAL: NY Bowhunter
I bought a pair of Savanah Shooters (scent lock). Nice tight fit and have decent warmth. When the weather turns nasty, I'll use a hand muff with a couple of hand warmers in there and leave the gloves on.
Same set up here. Tried the heavy glove thing too, doesn't work. The muff is the way to go and a great place to keep a call or binocs handy and warm. I don't use the scent-lok gloves when it is really cold because they seem to trap moisture and feel clammy. Then I use a light acrylic glove.