Shadow,

He is probablly a "official" 9 point, but in PA, he would be a 12 or 13. I have other pics of him from when he was in velvet and you can see them. There are 3 little stickers off the bottom of his bases, you can see one in this pic. They probablly aren't legal points, but in PA they count

Now, another thing that my best friend pointed out is that this bucks front left leg (his front left leg) looks to be messed up. Right above the hoof seems awfully thick compared to his other legs.