Which do you prefer? A rattle bag or actual antlers?

I have in the past used a rattle bag. This year I decided to cut a couple of antlers off a skull plate I had hanging around and use them for rattleing.

What I've found is a rattle bag is 100% (maybe more) more conveient then antlers but IMO antlers had a much better sound. I'm just curious what everyone else uses and if you'd like to post what has yeilded the best results I'd be interested in that as well.

Thanks,
Adams