i have a mossburg 500 and used it a lot for awhile. shoots real well and handles nice. mine is magna-ported and has very little recoil however it is very loud. i don't use it much anymore because i got a 20 gauge remington 11-87 i like better.

i never shot a benelli so i can't say anything good/bad

however if i had to do it all over i would go with the benelli