I have tried all these. I am now using a climber about 70% of the time, especially during the rut. The shoe spikes are terrible. I don't think you'll like them. If I can keep a stand up overnight I like the climbing sticks. I prefer the ones that you can put together on the ground then lean up against the tree. The strap on steps are ok, but until you get your full weight on the step they can slide. My favorite is the climber. I bought a huntertsview from walmart on clearance for about 65 dollars. Its a little heavy but very comfortable.