Update: I called Alpine Archery to ask why in the world they advertise and sell a 3 arrow quiver that doesn't hold three arrows. The guy was helpful and admitted it was tight, but suggested I slide one of the arrow grippers down from the top (near the hood) to the bottom. He said this will allow enough adjustment to make the three broadheads fit. It will be tight, but it won't rub. I also told him I could not punch the broadhead thru the foam and he said they came out with a lower density foam and would send it to me free.

I guess they are still working out a few kinks, but maybe this quiver will work afterall. It wasn't inexpensive at $35, so if it doesn't work, it sounds like i can trade for a Quickee at almost 1/2 the cost and be happy.