In reading the responces what I see is a clear picture. I don't doubt for one minute than we all would help someone learn what it takes to consistently get on a good deer. Luck plays into it a little but mostly it comes from walking the land and reading sign the 9 months of the year we can't hunt.

Putting someone on a stand and saying shoot the first 10 pointer that comes by dose them no good. Yes they killed a good buck but can they do it again on their own? If someone is willing to walk the countless miles all the time reading sign, studying maps and aerial photo they will learn what to look for and were to set up and what it takes. This is 100% more beneficial then letting them sit in your stand for an afternoon to kill a good buck.