I want a tip that will fly straight, tear up the deer, leave a nice blood trail, and will hold up so I can reuse it.
Most any broadhead out there will do that IF:
you take time to tune the bow and arrow so they are matched to one another.
They will all pretty much leave a nice bloodtrail IF:
You place the arrow where it cut large arteries and vanes, produce a low exit hole so all this blood can drain to the ground.
The reuse part depends on what your arrow runs into, either on its way to the deer or leaveing the deer. If you hit large rocks on a pass through not many broadheads are going to be reuseable.
Good luck.