Only you can answer that question. Since you need new arrows either way it might be worth looking into Beman. Perhaps instead of buying 1 dozen pickup 1/2 dozen of Beman and 1/2 dozen of another arrow so you can see which works best?

I've been comparing my ICS Hunters to the Gold Tip XT's that I recently picked up. So far I'm not able to see a difference.

-Jeramy