Bryan, I've never shot a Mathews but I have shot several other brands over the years and I think I have found a keeper in BowTech. The only thing that I've found that I don't like is the design of the grip so I shoot without one. Not a big deal because I used to take my grip off other brands too. I think the best way to decide if a BowTech is for you is to try one out for yourself and see what you think and not so much on others opinions. Most bows look good hanging on the rack but until you get one in the hand to feel it, draw it, and shoot it that should help you decide.