Do what's best for your situation and don't overemphasize what is needed over the next hill, unless you want to walk over that hill and help shoot some of those deer, (that's an option).
We are doing what is right for our situation. Farmers are complaining about crop damage, residents are complaining about damage to their gardens and roadkills are increasing. Simply put , the herd needs to be controled where we hunt and in every other woodlot in 5 C.
What you are telling us to do is ignore the experts, ignore the complaints from our neighbors and just manage the herd to produce more bucks. Personally I think that would be irresponsible.