Thanks all, I still can't decide if it's arrow spine or the arrows just aren't recovering fast enough.
5" vanes would be ok to try, but feathers are out of the question here in the Great Northwest, just too much rain.

I was thinking that with such a short arrow, the 2413's would be borderline too stiff, and hitting to the Right seems to indicate that as well.
But with the arrows on the money at the longer yardages it could be recovery.

With $100 in tags and needing food and gas money, there's no way I'll be able to convince my bride to drop more money on carbons.

And easy on the dog BOWFANATIC, around my house they get more attention than me.