I would say your rest might be a tad high and your nocking point might be a little low in order to get these result's ,check your arrow while nocked to make sure that your arrow is absolutely level then just move your nock up an 1/8 inch and try shooting again. Next try dropping your rest 1/8 and try your shot again .Hopefully after that you can start re adjusting your sight into position that you like .

nubo