I've been through every dang deer target there is, and I finally gave up on them.

I went to one of those white bag targets that are filled with plastic. They last a couple years for me...and the arrows truly pull out with two fingers.

The fact that I don't ever shoot field points made me go to these targets. The broadheads were tearing up my other targets, and these seem to be great. Cheap, too. Mine was around $30.