He makes some good points, but those two examples of recovered deer require a person to make some pretty major assumptions. He has no way of knowing if the broadheads recovered from those deer were sharp or not when they hit the deer. It's ridiculous to assume that they were dull. It would be just as accurate to assume that the people who shot those deer were left handed, and that those recovered deer were proof that left-handed people shouldn't hunt.

And please, an animal shot through the center of it's heart is not going to survive. I don't care if the broadhead was dull as a brick.

My BS detector is pegged.