Last season, my brother-in-law took aim at a buck. He didn't hear it approach, but when he saw it, it was wobbling. Anyway, he took aim, and the thing keeled over before he could squeeze the trigger!
He went up to the deer, and it had been hit a couple times. Well, he waited about a half hour, nobody showed up. He dressed it out -- for the other hunter -- nobody showed up. After a total of one hour, he tagged it and took it home!
Another example of slob hunting. No one showed up even looking for the deer? Good lord does that sort of stuff get my blood boiling!! Atleast the deer happened to go by your brother-in-law and he was able to tag it and make use of the meat.