Well , I have heard of people sucking on a apple, to hide their breath, why not smell like a tobaco barn.Will you kill a deer while dipping, probably, Will it be a wall hanger? It probably won't depend on on your choice of scoll or coppenhagen,but, your other hunting skills. Damn, if I wasn't afraid of losing my lower lip, I would still be dipping.I loved that Scoll. I kinda liked Pell Mell too, but gave that up long time ago.