Mike, I have a TuffBuck and it does stop the arrows very nicely. I've only shot Vapors into it so far. I see that your link said that you can shoot braodheads into it, and you can, but,........You can't get em out! I shot mine with a Rocket Ultimate Steel 75, I ended up having to remove the nock and gently tap on the arrow with a small wooden block to expose the BH. Then unscrew it and finally pull the arrow back out. Then I guess I had a mental block and must've thought it was a fluke, SO I DID IT AGAIN,.......same results. As for pulling fieldtipped arrows, I'd say it's pretty tough until the foam gets a little weaker where the arrows hits. Now that mines finally "broke in" I like it alot. I still am not willing to try another BH yet. I've been thinkin of getting a Carbon Buck mid-section to slip into my TuffBuck body and try this. I just hope that BH's can be removed easier. I have not heard ANY reviews on the CarbonBuck though. If you go with the Carbon, let me know what ya think.