You guys are right. However, my taxidermist told me he would probably repair the tine because the buck originally had it. He says he does it all the time. Like I said, I was and still am 65% going to keep him with the broken tine, I am not adding points and never would consider it. This buck did originally have the tine. What if the tine broke after he crashed into a tree after you shot him. He wasn't dead yet, would you repair the tine?

I know I'll end up keeping him with the broken tine, was just curious to see what your opinions were.

But thanks for being such a smart-a$$ 6ptsika. Makes you look like a real jerk.

Thanks to those of you who actually read my post. I appreciate the friendly advice.