Outdoor,

It's been nice chatting with you also. If I have offended you, it was not my intentions, I apologize, we all come here to learn and share each others views as we all are hunters. But you will always have interesting reviews of the do nots and should you topics, and I guess it just boils down to your own disgression, when it comes right down to that choice--when put in that situation--and just hopefully you try to make that right decision... I know that there is'nt a perfect hunter out there, but we as hunters have the ability to always improve and learn from our own mistakes, or even other hunters mistakes they have shared with us and also teach our young fellow hunters, the rights and wrongs as we have been taught either by our dad, friend, instructor, or a mentor or even ourself...
I tip my hat to you for starting a very interesting thread as it can be a very debatable subject...I know it started out about rifle loads into an elk neck, but when you finished up on the summary you stated about a neck shot on a deer with bow. I will just say if you make the shot, you have to live with that shot, wether it be good or bad...