Thanks for the responses. You make a good point Bowfanatic. The Liberty was set at 65lbs and the Outback was a 70lb bow backed a little (not sure how much). Hawgz, I was aware that the draw length would make a difference and took that into consideration.

Don't get me wrong, I really liked the OB (especially for the price - $579). However, I preferred the way the Justice felt in my hand (lighter weight and smaller grip). Since I couldn't shoot the Justice (the one at the shop was sold) I shot the Liberty and loved it. But it is too expensive for me ($679 here and not sure if it worth the extra price). Since the Justice is in the same price range as the Outback, I am considering it as an alternative. Right now I am wondering if I am crazy to even consider another bow over a Mathews. It's not often that the Mathews is the cheaper bow, and around here Mathews are very popular.

Right now I am sitting on the fence and would like some input to lean one way or another. Thanks again for your help.