Hi bigbulls,

That's a tough one. Personally I think both of those pistols are great for that purpose. I also happen to have a Para-Ordnance P-12 chambered for .45 ACP. It is also a carry gun.....though not my only carry gun.

Would you feel comfortable carrying a 1911 in Condition 1, "cocked and locked"? If so...it is a personal protection pistol with few peers. If you are not sure how you feel about carrying in Condition 1....then the XD becomes a better first choice automatically! I'd have no qualms recommending a 1911 to an experienced shooter of the 1911, (I don't know your experience). But for someone that doesn't have much experience with a 1911.....I'd personally recommend the Springfield XD.

Whichever of the two you carry.....I believe that as long as you did your part....they'd certainly do theirs. They are both great pistols!

Dave