Ok, Ok, I was stretching it a bit about shooting off the shelf

Good luck to all with their WB's, I vow to no longer discredit the rest, but on the other hand I will not recommend it either. It goes against all other principles of arrow rest design, and as such, I won't use one whether it works or not. Yes, I am being closed minded, but that's how I feel.
Pinwheel, I don't doubt what you are saying, I've been around this board long enough to know that you damn well know what you are talking about. I still won't give it a try, I've never had a problem with arrows falling off the rest and I don't want to worry about my feathers getting damaged.