I've never used goat tuff so I can't say whether anything is better or not. On the rare occassions I fletch up vanes on carbon, I use one of the cyanoacrylate 'super glue' gels. Bondini works good. Best thing about it is you can find that kind of glue in any WalMart and it's a lot less expensive than archery specialty glue. Frankly, I think it's all the same anyway.

For feathers, I won't willingly use anything but Bohning fletching tape.

As for jigs, I'm using a Bitzenberger. It's the best jig you can get, IMO. There was a JoJan Multi-fletcher on my workbench for many years, but when I started using modern glue, I didn't need to have six shafts working at the same time any more. So, it was the Bitz. The BPE Pro model jig is also a decent one and quite a bit less expensive than the Bitz.