sky guy, the Encore is a great rifle (I have one in .243). However, it is not the gun I would use for fast offhand shots. As a single shot, I believe it is much better suited to precision (i.e., take your time, use support, etc.) shooting.

For a fast handling .44 I'd give serious consideration to the Marlin 1894P. I have an 1894S that I really like, but the P version has an even shorter (carbine length) barrel that should make it even better for quick shots. I'd get the Ashley Outdoors scout scope mount (install it yourself on the Marlins) and a Leupold or Burris scout scope and you'd have a dandy .44 mag scout for fast, accurate offhand shooting, with the potential of very fast follow-up shots.

As I said, I love my Encore, but wouldn't use it for the application you describe. I'd be happier with the Marlin.

cogito, ergo armatus sum.