I have fletched my share of arrows and found that the super glue gell works great. However this can be tricky with the arizona fletcher. The glue wont soak into the base of the fletch. After fletching I pulled as hard as I could on the fletch and the feather ripped before the base let loose. I would't recommend fletching tape. I have seen several people use this and the feathers will statrt to move with time. The fletch Jig should stay on a little longer as there are a few more forces working against the glue until it hardens. Hope this helps.