I would buy the Elite and the best deal out there is
www.natchezss.com Trust me I just went through all of this. At Natchez some of there elite's aren't listed on the web site so you have to call or check the flyer at the web site.
Keep in mind that the elite has to have a scope on it. It doesn't come with iron sights and you cannot add them to it. I chose the Disc extreme because we have a 1X scope law in WI during the muzzleloader season.
I called Knight and they said the accuracy was about the same with the two rifles, but the elite is better balanced. After owning the extreme for a couple of months I see what they mean. The gun gets heavy when you are holding on a deer for awhile.
I ended up adding a red dot to my Knight and now wish I would have bought the Elite. I bought mine for Natchez for $420.00. The price was $458.00, but they came down because I bought two of them. I buy tons of hunting stuff and they are ALWAYS the cheapest and if not they will beat anyone if you tell them wehre you saw it cheaper.
I haven't shot at 100yds yet but at 50yds I am almost in the same hole each time from a sand bag rest. 100grain triple seven with 250 dead centers.
Before buying I called Knight three or four times with questions. They alway spent all the time I needed to answer me and never were anything but helpful. In fact it was like calling someone I go hunting with. They even sent me next day air samples of their red hot bullets and had any ballistic infor I needed.
To answer the other person about inlines being like centerfires. Yes you are right. My priority is an extra season and another chance to hunt the mighty whittail. I love the idea of making one shot count, but when I do shoot I want it to be there. I hunt Buffalo County in WI and see world class deer. I am not afraid to admit that I am all about the trophy and personally like a beef steak better than venison any day of the week. I hunt almost every day during the season with my bow, rifle, and muzzleloader and can't get enough.
Sorry to get off topic, I just wanted to let some of the people that don't understand why we use these "modern" inline smoke poles. I do have great respect for the guys that are into tradition (along with the stick bows) but it's just not my thing.
Cybersniper