jmac,
Just curious why you decided to go with the Justice. I also shot these two bows side by side & agree that they are very similar. It was a tough decision between the two but I ended up with the Liberty. The Liberty runs about $85-$90 more than the Justice but I tried not to let that influence my decision. For me, the Justice just felt a little too light & was just a little too short for my liking, but it is an excellent bow & wasn't an easy choice.