Ok first of all the antlers were not broken, they were SHED, not broken SHED which means there were no "three inch stubs" (rcw280). And Jimpok you might not know about rules for WI tags but it is buck or doe, its antler or atlerless, so if a nyb buck was shot, it would be antlerless cuz it has anlters under 3 inches. It has nothing to do with the sex of the deer.