You didn't mention if you will be shooting broadheads into your new target, so I will offer this for standard fieldpoints. I have an Eternity target from Morrell that is three years old, and I shoot everyday, weather permitting. This target has taken thousands of shots without a single pass-thru. I have replaced the outside cover once and in terms of maintenance, you simply lay it flat and jump on it to recompress material and alternate shooting between the front and back of the target. For 50 bucks, I simply cannot imagine a better more durable target. Good shopping.